⭐⭐⭐⭐

101 minutes ‧ Unrated ‧ 2020
Cast: Michael Alogna, Henry Arango, James Bidgood
Director: Michael Seligman, Jennifer Tiexiera
Genres: Documentary, Queer

P.S. Burn This Letter Please is a deeply moving documentary, notable not only for its subject but also for its unique discovery story. It begins when someone uncovers a box of sixty-year-old letters hidden in an abandoned storage unit. These letters, written by drag performers and their friends, are rich in wit, warmth, and coded language, and are signed with pseudonyms to protect the writers’ identities. This aspect is vital. The letters are not merely part of the film — they form its core and heartbeat.

The film’s title, P.S. Burn This Letter Please, perfectly captures the risks these writers faced. In an era when being queer or dressing in drag could mean arrest, shame, or violence. The letters offer a glimpse into a hidden world — one that could easily have disappeared if they had been destroyed, as so many were.

Using these letters as a guide, the documentary traces the lives of the people who wrote them and explores the vibrant drag scene in New York before Stonewall. It shows how, despite living in fear, these performers built friendships, found joy, and created a sense of community. As the filmmakers track down the real names behind the pseudonyms, the film becomes part detective story, part history lesson. We hear directly from people who lived through that era, and their memories bring the past to life.

What makes the documentary truly special is how warm and engaging it feels. It never slips into dry facts or distant storytelling. Instead, the personalities of the letter writers shine through — funny, clever, stylish, and full of life. Even when the film explores dark or difficult moments, the letters themselves are bursting with character and humor, making the story feel alive and full of heart.

P.S. Burn This Letter Please is more than a history lesson — it’s an act of remembrance and revival. It shows how something as small as a saved letter can help us hold onto the struggles, joys, and humanity of a community that might otherwise have been lost. The film is a powerful reminder that even the most ordinary things can make an extraordinary difference.

Copyright ©️2026 by Frank Gaimari