My Own Private Idaho

Frank’s Film Review: My Own Private Idaho
⭐⭐⭐⭐/5

Here’s my take on My Own Private Idaho (1991), directed by Gus Van Sant. It’s a strange yet fascinating film that lingers long after you’ve watched it. At its heart, it’s about figuring out who you are and what it means to search for love and a sense of belonging. Keanu Reeves and River Phoenix both deliver incredible performances, making the story feel raw and deeply emotional.

The movie follows two young men living on the fringes of society, trying to find meaning in their lives. River Phoenix plays Mike, a sensitive soul with narcolepsy who’s desperate to find his mother and a place where he truly belongs. Keanu Reeves is Scott, the rebellious son of a mayor who rejects his privileged future to live recklessly. Despite their differences, the two form a bond and set off on a journey that takes them from Idaho to Seattle, Portland, and then Italy. Along the way, they meet a variety of people, each encounter adding to their story. Mike is always searching for something more profound, while Scott often seems to treat life as a game, not taking things too seriously.

Keanu Reeves was still early in his career when he made this, and you can tell he’s finding his footing. But his portrayal of Scott feels genuine. Reeves doesn’t have the same intensity as Phoenix, but his quieter performance fits the role perfectly.

River Phoenix, though, is the heart of the film. He plays Mike as someone broken but still holding onto hope. The campfire scene, where Mike confesses his feelings to Scott, is unforgettable. Phoenix’s performance is subtle yet incredibly powerful, and knowing he passed away so young makes it all the more poignant. This movie is a reminder of just how talented he was.

Visually, the film is stunning. There are wide, lonely shots of highways that capture the emptiness the characters feel, and then there are surreal moments—like moving clouds or dream sequences—that give you a glimpse into Mike’s inner world. The cinematography adds so much depth to the story.

The only aspect I found myself questioning was the film’s ending. It felt as though Gus Van Sant, who also served as the screenwriter, wrapped things up too abruptly, leaving too many unresolved questions. I craved some form of closure—perhaps a reaction or even retaliation from Mike, or maybe a truce between the two men.

No matter how it concludes, My Own Private Idaho stands as a true masterpiece. It’s more than just a film—it’s an immersive experience. Every element seamlessly comes together: the powerful performances, the raw emotions, and the stunning visuals. If you’re in search of something truly unique, this is an absolute must-watch.

Frank Gaimari is an author, film reviewer, and actor based in Seattle, Washington. He lives with his husband and their two golden retrievers. Learn more about his work at http://FrankGaimari.com.