The Boys in the Band (1970)

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Mart Crowley’s The Boys in the Band started as a groundbreaking play in 1968 and was brought to the screen in 1970 by director William Friedkin. At a time when discussions about homosexuality were often taboo, this film boldly tackled the subject, offering an honest and, at times, raw look at the lives of gay men. This isn’t just a movie; it’s a heartfelt, emotional snapshot of a time and a community wrestling with self-acceptance and society’s judgment.

The story takes place in a New York City apartment where gay friends gather to celebrate a birthday. What begins as a fun evening full of banter and laughs soon dives into deeper waters, exploring the pain of internalized homophobia and how it shapes their lives. These struggles manifest in self-destructive behaviors like heavy drinking and moments of cruelty, but there are also scenes of loyalty and humor that reveal their strength and humanity.

The meaning of The Boys in the Band runs deep. It acts as a metaphor for the internalized homophobia and self-loathing experienced by many gay men in the 1960s. Just as band members are united by their shared experiences in making music, the characters in this story are connected through their everyday struggles, joys, and identities. But the “band” here also reflects the bittersweet reality of their camaraderie—while they support one another, they sometimes lash out in ways that mirror their inner turmoil. The title encapsulates the film’s core, where moments of harmony are punctuated by discord, reflecting the emotional highs and lows of living in a world that largely refuses to accept them.

The cast delivers unforgettable performances that bring every character to life. Kenneth Nelson shines as Michael, the party’s host, whose charm masks his deep insecurities. His moments of vulnerability are both gripping and hard to watch. Leonard Frey plays Harold, the hilariously sarcastic birthday boy who uses his wit to cover up his doubts about aging and self-worth. Their fraught friendship becomes the film’s emotional core, and their exchanges are as biting as they are revealing.

Other cast members include Cliff Gorman as the flamboyant and unapologetically campy Emory, whose humor often masks his heartbreak, and Laurence Luckinbill as Hank, a reserved character struggling with his identity. Add Peter White as Alan, a presumed straight friend who shows up uninvited, and it’s clear this party is destined for drama. Alan’s presence stirs tensions, bringing suppressed truths and buried emotions crashing to the surface.

While the film grossed $3.5 million at the box office—a modest success in financial terms—its cultural impact far outweighed the numbers. Critics were largely positive, praising its bold storytelling and performances, though the unflinching portrayal of these flawed, complex men took some aback. Audiences were presented with a story that depicted real struggles, highlighting a community that had often been overlooked or misunderstood.

Even decades after its release, the film’s themes remain relevant, which is why its 2018 Broadway revival received so much acclaim. Featuring an openly gay cast, the production won the Tony Award for Best Revival of a Play in 2019, a testament to Crowley’s work’s lasting power and importance.

What makes The Boys in the Band endure is its ability to make us laugh and cry while addressing issues that connect with audiences across generations. It gives viewers an intimate look into the lives of its characters—their conflicts, joys, and raw humanity. While some moments are tough to watch, they’re equally hard to forget, making this film a must-see.

Watching The Boys in the Band isn’t just an exercise in cinematic appreciation; it’s an experience that stays with you long after the film ends. Whether it’s your first watch or your tenth, this film can look you in the eye and remind you of the strength to be honest with yourself and the world. It’s a classic that transcends time and remains as gripping today as when it first debuted. If you love movies that challenge, provoke, and move you, this one deserves a top spot on your must-watch list.

Frank Gaimari is an author and film reviewer in Seattle. He lives with his husband and their two golden retrievers. You can learn more about his work at http://www.FrankGaimari.com.